The main difference between Modash, Social Cat, and Influencer Hero lies in their focus and scope. Modash is built primarily for influencer discovery and analytics, ideal for brands that already have outreach and management processes in place. Social Cat, on the other hand, focuses on product seeding and gifting collaborations, making it great for Shopify eCommerce startups and small D2C brands looking to connect quickly with micro-influencers for free product exchanges. Influencer Hero takes an all-in-one approach — combining discovery, outreach automation, influencer CRM, affiliate tracking, and performance analytics — designed for scaling D2C brands that want to manage influencer marketing end-to-end in one platform.
In this article, we’ll dive deep into the comparison between Modash, Social Cat, and Influencer Hero, exploring their features, pricing, pros, and cons to help you decide which platform best fits your brand’s influencer marketing strategy.
The biggest difference lies in how wide each platform’s reach is. Modash supports influencer discovery across Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube, making it strong for brands running multi-platform campaigns. Social Cat focuses mostly on Instagram and TikTok creators for gifting, while Influencer Hero combines all major platforms under one system — ideal for D2C brands managing influencer collaborations at scale.
Modash is primarily a discovery tool and doesn’t handle influencer communication or campaign management. Social Cat automates gifting campaigns but lacks end-to-end tracking. Influencer Hero, in contrast, functions as a full influencer CRM, allowing teams to manage outreach, contracts, approvals, affiliate links, and payments all from one dashboard.
Social Cat integrates directly with Shopify to automate product gifting, while Modash mainly relies on data export through CSV or API. Influencer Hero goes further by connecting with Shopify, WooCommerce, Klaviyo, and Google Analytics — streamlining gifting, code generation, and revenue tracking for D2C operations.
When it comes to analytics, Modash provides detailed influencer insights like audience demographics and fake follower detection but doesn’t show sales performance. Social Cat offers engagement metrics and basic campaign visibility. Influencer Hero ties influencer activity directly to sales, offering real-time analytics on clicks, conversions, and ROI — a key advantage for performance-focused brands.
Affiliate functionality is where Influencer Hero clearly stands out. Modash and Social Cat lack affiliate or sales attribution features, while Influencer Hero includes automated affiliate and discount tracking with payout calculation, making it ideal for brands wanting to connect influencer campaigns to real revenue results.
While Modash starts around $120/month, it scales up with data limits and team size, making it best for established marketing teams focused on analytics. Social Cat pricing ranges from $99 to $299/month, offering a cost-effective option for small Shopify or eCommerce brands running product seeding programs. Influencer Hero starts around $649/month (based on demo data) and provides an all-in-one influencer marketing suite suitable for growing D2C and enterprise-level brands.
If your main focus is influencer discovery and analytics, Modash is the strongest option. It’s built for teams that want to find influencers across Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube with advanced filters and audience insights — but it stops there. You’ll still need separate tools or manual workflows for outreach, campaign management, and tracking ROI.
Social Cat is ideal for small Shopify brands or early-stage D2C startups running product gifting campaigns. Its matchmaking system simplifies connecting with micro-influencers, but it lacks automation, analytics, and affiliate tracking. It’s great for quick collaborations, not for scaling or running long-term influencer programs.
Influencer Hero stands out as the best all-in-one solution for growing D2C brands. With deep Shopify integrations, automated outreach, full CRM, and built-in affiliate tracking, it replaces multiple tools with one. Brands choose Influencer Hero because it connects influencer marketing directly to sales and ROI, not just engagement metrics.
Modash is an influencer marketing platform built for brands, agencies, and in-house marketing teams that want to scale influencer programs with data-backed discovery, campaign tracking, and audience analytics. Its core value is enabling brands to find relevant influencers across Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube, assess their authenticity (via metrics like fake-follower detection or audience demographics), and then monitor campaign performance — all in one interface. Modash claims a database of 350M+ creators across platforms.
Here are five features that make Modash stand out — especially when considered from the perspective of e-commerce, growing D2C brands, and scaling influencer operations:
Modash is best for D2C and e-commerce brands (from startups to mid-size enterprises) that want powerful influencer discovery, campaign tracking, and affiliate workflows — without needing to stitch together multiple standalone tools.
Social Cat is a matchmaking platform that connects Shopify and D2C brands with micro-influencers for product gifting collaborations. Instead of focusing on paid influencer campaigns, Social Cat simplifies influencer marketing by automating the process of finding, matching, and managing creators willing to promote products in exchange for gifts. It’s particularly useful for startups and small eCommerce stores looking to build awareness through authentic, user-generated content without committing to large influencer budgets.
1. Automated Influencer Matching: Social Cat automatically pairs brands with influencers who fit their product niche, audience, and budget. This feature helps Shopify and small D2C brands save hours on manual outreach and focus on collaborations that convert into user-generated content.
2. Shopify Integration: Built specifically with Shopify eCommerce stores in mind, this integration streamlines the process of sending gifted products to influencers, tracking shipments, and confirming collaborations — all directly through the Shopify dashboard.
3. Gifting Campaign Management: The platform enables brands to launch, manage, and review multiple gifting campaigns at once. Each campaign includes influencer reviews, content usage rights, and creator performance tracking, which is particularly valuable for product-based D2C brands.
4. Creator Review & Vetting System: Brands can read and leave reviews for creators they’ve collaborated with, ensuring higher-quality partnerships. This transparency makes it easier for emerging brands to avoid unreliable creators and build lasting influencer relationships.
5. Content Usage Rights: All plans include unlimited content usage rights, allowing brands to repurpose influencer-generated photos and videos across ads, social media, or email campaigns — a big plus for startups leveraging UGC to boost brand credibility.
Social Cat is best for Shopify brands, D2C startups, and small eCommerce teams that want to run low-cost influencer campaigns through product gifting instead of paid sponsorships.
Based on our research, Social Cat operates on monthly subscription plans with no long-term contracts:
No annual commitment is required — brands can scale up or down month-to-month depending on their campaign needs.
Social Cat does not offer any free tools outside of its subscription plans. However, it occasionally provides free trial campaigns or demo credits that let brands explore the platform before committing to a paid plan.
Influencer Hero is an all-in-one influencer marketing platform built for Shopify, WooCommerce, and D2C brands to manage every part of their influencer marketing in one place — from discovery and outreach to affiliate tracking and performance analytics. Unlike platforms that only handle discovery or gifting, Influencer Hero provides an integrated system that automates influencer communication, manages collaborations, tracks sales through discount codes and affiliate links, and simplifies payments — making it ideal for scaling influencer programs efficiently.
1. All-in-One Influencer CRM: Influencer Hero combines influencer search, outreach, gifting, campaign management, and affiliate tracking into one centralized CRM. This allows D2C brands to manage hundreds of influencer relationships simultaneously, reducing the need for multiple tools like spreadsheets, Gmail, or manual tracking.
2. Deep Shopify & WooCommerce Integrations: Designed for eCommerce brands, Influencer Hero integrates directly with Shopify and WooCommerce, automating discount code creation, affiliate link tracking, and product gifting. Brands can instantly attribute sales to influencers and monitor ROI from their storefronts in real time.
3. Automated Outreach & Communication: The platform includes built-in outreach automation, enabling marketers to send personalized bulk messages, follow-ups, and reminders directly to creators. This is especially useful for growing teams managing outreach at scale while keeping the communication tone authentic.
4. Real-Time Performance Tracking & ROI Analytics: Influencer Hero offers advanced analytics for clicks, conversions, and revenue generated by each influencer. Brands using Shopify or Amazon can see which creators are driving actual sales — not just engagement — helping them reinvest in top performers and optimize budgets.
5. Creator Dashboard for Influencers: The integrated Creator Dashboard allows influencers to view their affiliate links, discount codes, and commission earnings in real time, creating transparency and trust. This feature helps brands build stronger, long-term partnerships by giving creators a clear view of performance and payouts.
Influencer Hero is best for Shopify, WooCommerce, and Amazon D2C brands that want to scale influencer and affiliate campaigns through automation, integrated analytics, and full campaign visibility in one unified platform.
Based on public information, Influencer Hero pricing starts around $649/month, depending on brand size, influencer volume, and feature usage.
Contracts are generally monthly or annual, with annual plans offering discounted rates and onboarding support.
Influencer Hero offers a wide range of free influencer marketing tools. Among them, you will find:
When comparing Modash, Social Cat and Influencer Hero, the biggest difference comes down to scope and functionality. Influencer Hero, takes a full-funnel approach. It not only helps you find the right influencers but also manages the entire relationship — from automated outreach and gifting to real-time performance tracking, affiliate management, and payments.
With direct Shopify and WooCommerce integrations, Influencer Hero connects influencer marketing directly to sales and ROI, making it the smarter choice for D2C brands looking to scale sustainably.
Book a free demo with Influencer Hero today to see how your brand can simplify influencer marketing, save time, and boost conversions — all in one place.
Schedule a Demo with one of our media experts below.
