How to Find Influencers Similar to Your Best Creators

How to Find Influencers Similar to Your Best Creators

November 20, 2026
|
Veröffentlicht
November 20, 2026
|
Aktualisiert
10 minutes
|
Lektüre
Malena Garcia
Malena Garcia
Sieh, welche Influencer Deinem Instagram folgen
Sie sind 8X häufiger bereit, mit Ihnen zusammenzuarbeiten
KOSTENLOSE LISTE ABRUFEN

How to Find Influencers Similar to Your Best Creators

Every brand has a few creators who outperform everyone else. They drive the most sales, their content gets reused in ads, and they say yes to every new launch. The problem is that there are never enough of them.

Finding more is harder than it sounds. In Sprout Social's 2026 research, 38% of marketers say finding creators who align with their target audience is a top challenge. The shortcut is to stop starting from scratch: use your best creators as the brief and search for influencers who look, post and perform like them.

That's what lookalike search does. In Influencer Hero, you pick a creator who already works for your brand, click Find lookalikes, and get a list of similar creators you can filter and add to a campaign in a few clicks. With the Influencer Hero MCP, you can do the same from ChatGPT or Claude. This guide walks you through the whole process.

 

Key Takeaways

  • Your best creators are your best brief: their content, audience and results tell you exactly who to look for next.
  • Pick your seed creators by results (sales, clicks, engagement), not by follower count or how much you like their content.
  • Lookalike search finds creators with a similar content style, audience and profile, so you don't have to describe what you want in words.
  • In Influencer Hero, you can start a lookalike search from any creator profile or from the Lookalike tab, then filter by email, verification and engagement rate.
  • With the Influencer Hero MCP, you can ask ChatGPT or Claude to find creators similar to your top performer and add them to a campaign in one prompt.

 

What Is a Lookalike Influencer Search?

A lookalike search uses one creator (the "seed") as the input and returns other creators with a similar profile: the type of content they post, how it looks, who their audience is and how big their account is. Instead of guessing the right keywords, you show the tool an example of what good looks like.

It works best when you already have creators who perform well. If you're just starting out, find your first creators by searching by content first, then use lookalikes once you know who drives results.

 

How to Find Influencers Similar to Your Best Creators

 

Step 1: Find Your Best Creators by Results

Start with data, not gut feeling. The creator with the prettiest feed isn't always the one who sells. Look at sales, clicks, conversion rate and content you've reused in ads, and pick 1–3 clear winners.

In Influencer Hero, open a creator's profile and go to the Affiliate tab. You'll see their clicks, referrals, sales, commission and a chart of clicks and sales over time, all tracked through their personal discount code and links.

Top Creator Affiliate Sales in Influencer Hero

In this example, @mara.trains drove 3,412 clicks and $11,846 in sales over 12 months with a 15% commission. That's the kind of creator you want more of.

 

Step 2: Define What Makes Them Work

Before you search, write down why your best creators perform. This helps you judge the lookalike results and spot the ones that only look similar on the surface.

What to copyWhat to look atWhere to find it in Influencer Hero
Results Sales, clicks, conversion rate and revenue per creator Affiliate tab on the creator profile
Content style Formats (Reels, carousels), topics, editing style and overall look Profile feed and the Content Wall
Audience Audience location, age and gender Creator analytics (View Analytics)
Performance Engagement rate, median engagement and median Reel plays Profile metrics
Size and location Follower range and the country the creator is based in Followers and location filters

 

Step 3: Open the Creator and Click "Find Lookalikes"

Open your best creator's profile in the Influencer Finder. Check that their engagement, median Reel plays, country and recent posts match what you saw in Step 2, then click Find lookalikes.

Find Lookalikes Button on an Influencer Profile in Influencer Hero

You can also go to the Lookalike tab in the Influencer Finder and paste the creator's handle or profile URL.

Lookalike Influencer Search in Influencer Hero

Step 4: Review the Lookalike Results

You get a list of creators similar to your seed, each with their three most recent posts, followers, engagement and engagement rate. Scan the recent posts first: the content should feel like it belongs next to your best creator's feed. Then use the match strictness (from Very Broad to Strict) to widen or narrow the list.

Lookalike Influencer Results in Influencer Hero

Want to go deeper on how the matching works? Read our guide to lookalike search.

Step 5: Filter and Add the Best Matches to a Campaign

Add filters to keep only the creators you can actually work with, such as "Has email: Yes", "Verified: Yes" or a minimum engagement rate. Select the creators you want and click Add to Campaign. They go straight into your outreach sequences and gifting flow.

Filtered Lookalike Influencers Added to a Campaign in Influencer Hero

Step 6: Repeat With Every New Top Performer

Lookalike search isn't a one-time task. Every time a new creator becomes a top performer, use them as a seed. You can also run lookalikes from several creators at once, or from a whole campaign, to find creators who match your best performers as a group. Over time, your creator program gets better with every round.

 

How to Find Similar Influencers With Influencer Hero MCP

If your team works in an AI assistant, you can run lookalike searches there too. The Influencer Hero MCP connects your Influencer Hero account to ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini, so the assistant can find your top performers, search for similar creators and add them to a campaign.

Influencer Hero MCP Lookalike Search in ChatGPT

Prompts you can try:

Prompt: @Influencer Hero Show me my top 5 creators by affiliate sales in the last 90 days.

Prompt: @Influencer Hero Find 20 creators similar to @[handle] with 10k–100k followers and an email, based in [country].

Prompt: @Influencer Hero From that list, keep creators with an engagement rate above 2% and add them to my "[campaign name]" campaign.

Most influencer marketing MCPs only pull data out. Influencer Hero's lets you take action, and the assistant asks for your approval before it changes anything in your account or uses credits.

 

Other Ways to Find Influencers Similar to Your Best Creators

No lookalike tool? You can still find similar creators by hand. It takes longer, but it works for a handful of creators:

  • Check Instagram's suggested accounts. Follow your best creator and look at the "Suggested for you" row on their profile.
  • Look at who they tag and collab with. Creators often post with friends in the same niche.
  • Browse their hashtags and comments. Other creators in the same niche often comment on each other's posts.
  • Ask them. Your best creators know other creators like them. A simple "know anyone who'd love this?" can bring great referrals.

 

Example: How Immersive Gamebox Doubled Down on Its Best Creators

Immersive Gamebox ran an always-on gifting program in the US and UK with Influencer Hero. The approach had two phases: first, test broadly to see whose content performs; then, focus on the winners. The team kept 50+ high-performing creators tagged by city and brought them back for game launches and new venue openings.

The result: 400+ influencer collaborations in 8 months, a 30% response rate and 300+ pieces of UGC across 25 cities. Your top performers tell you who to find next, and lookalike search turns that into a repeatable process. Read the full Immersive Gamebox case study.

 

Common Mistakes to Avoid

  • Picking seeds by follower count. A big creator with average sales makes a bad seed. Use results.
  • Using only one seed. One creator can be a fluke. Two or three top performers give you a clearer pattern.
  • Skipping the content check. Similar audience doesn't always mean similar content. Always look at recent posts.
  • Not tracking results per creator. Without a personal code or link per creator, you can't tell who your best creators are. Set up affiliate tracking from day one.

 

Final Thoughts

Finding influencers similar to your best creators is the fastest way to scale what already works. Find your top performers by results, write down what makes them work, run a lookalike search, filter for fit, and repeat every time a new creator breaks out.

With Influencer Hero, the whole loop happens in one place: affiliate tracking shows you who your best creators are, lookalike search finds more like them, and the MCP lets you do it all from ChatGPT or Claude. Plans start at $649/month.

Want to find creators like your top performers? Book a demo and we'll run a lookalike search on one of your best creators live.

Zusammenfassung
Dies ist ein Text in einem Div-Block.
Dies ist ein Text in einem Div-Block.
Preisgestaltung/Monat
Shopify Bewertungen
Dies ist etwas Text in einem Div-Block.
Dies ist Text in einem Div-Block.
Dies ist Text in einem Div-Block.
Dies ist etwas Text in einem Div-Block.
Dies ist Text in einem Div-Block.
Dies ist Text in einem Div-Block.
Dies ist etwas Text in einem Div-Block.
Dies ist Text in einem Div-Block.
Dies ist Text in einem Div-Block.
Dies ist etwas Text in einem Div-Block.
Dies ist Text in einem Div-Block.
Dies ist Text in einem Div-Block.
Dies ist etwas Text in einem Div-Block.
Dies ist Text in einem Div-Block.
Dies ist Text in einem Div-Block.
Dies ist etwas Text in einem Div-Block.
Dies ist Text in einem Div-Block.
Dies ist Text in einem Div-Block.
Dies ist etwas Text in einem Div-Block.
Dies ist Text in einem Div-Block.
Dies ist Text in einem Div-Block.
Mehr erfahren
Dies ist etwas Text in einem Div-Block.
Dies ist Text in einem Div-Block.
Dies ist Text in einem Div-Block.
Häufig gestellte Fragen
What is a lookalike influencer?
A lookalike influencer is a creator with a similar content style, audience and profile to a creator you already know performs well for your brand.
How do I know who my best creators are?
Track results per creator with personal discount codes and affiliate links. In Influencer Hero, the Affiliate tab on each creator profile shows clicks, referrals, sales and commission, so you can rank creators by revenue.
Can I find lookalikes for more than one creator at once?
Yes. You can run a lookalike search from several seed creators, or from a whole campaign, to find creators who match your best performers as a group.
Can ChatGPT find influencers similar to a creator?
Not reliably on its own, because it has no live creator data. Connected to Influencer Hero through the MCP, ChatGPT and Claude can run lookalike searches on real creator data and add the results to a campaign.
How many lookalike creators should I contact?
Plan on contacting several times more creators than you need. In the Immersive Gamebox program, the response rate was 30% and the onboarding rate was 10%.

Beliebteste Blog-Beiträge

Steigern Sie Ihren ROI mit Influencer Marketing

Über 1.200 Marken und mehr als 150 Agenturen skalieren ihre Creator-Programme mit Influencer Hero.