Incentivized reviews are everywhere, and in 2024, over 95% of consumers read product reviews before making a purchase, while 58% are even willing to pay more for items with positive feedback.
With that kind of influence, it's no surprise that brands turn to incentives to generate more reviews, especially during product launches. But here’s the thing: While incentivized reviews can build trust and drive conversions, they also raise some serious ethical and legal questions. Are they even allowed? Are brands playing by the rules, or are they skating on thin ice?
In this article, we’ll break down what incentivized reviews are, how they work, and how to use them responsibly without crossing any lines.
Incentivized reviews are product or service reviews written by individuals who received some form of compensation in return—whether it’s a free product, a discount, a gift card, or even direct payment.
The idea is simple: encourage customers or influencers to try a product and share their honest feedback in exchange for a reward. While the goal isn’t to buy a positive review, there’s often concern about bias if incentives aren't properly disclosed.
When done ethically and transparently, incentivized reviews can still offer genuine insights that help other consumers make informed decisions.
Incentives can take many forms, depending on the brand’s strategy and target audience. Some companies offer free products or samples in exchange for a review, particularly when launching a new item.
Others provide store credit, exclusive discounts, or even entries into sweepstakes or giveaways. In influencer partnerships, monetary compensation is also common.
Regardless of the reward, the key is to ensure that the reviewer is free to express their honest opinion and that the incentive is disclosed upfront to maintain credibility and comply with regulations.
The main difference between incentivized and organic reviews lies in whether compensation is involved. Incentivized reviews are tied to a reward or payment, while organic reviews are written voluntarily by customers without any external prompt or benefit.
Organic reviews tend to be perceived as more trustworthy because they come with no strings attached. However, properly disclosed incentivized reviews can still be highly credible, especially when reviewers are encouraged to share honest, balanced feedback.
Ultimately, transparency is the deciding factor—whether a review was incentivized or organic, honesty and clear disclosure are what build real trust with an audience.
There are different reasons behind choosing incentivized reviews to boost your brand, here are some of them:
One of the biggest challenges brands face when launching a new product is building up a base of reviews. Without social proof, potential buyers may hesitate to make a purchase. Incentivized reviews help solve this problem by generating initial buzz and quickly populating product pages with authentic user feedback.
This early activity can improve conversion rates and give new products the traction they need to succeed in competitive markets.
Beyond increasing review volume, incentivized reviews provide valuable customer feedback that brands can use to refine products, fix issues, or identify strengths. When customers are encouraged to share detailed thoughts, companies get direct insights into real-world usage, preferences, and pain points.
This feedback loop can be critical for improving product quality and customer satisfaction over time.
More reviews often mean better visibility on eCommerce platforms and search engines. Many marketplaces and algorithms prioritize products with higher review counts, making it easier for incentivized items to rank higher and attract attention.
At the same time, seeing a range of honest reviews—including both pros and cons—can increase a product’s credibility and make consumers more confident in their purchase decisions.
For sellers, especially on competitive platforms like Amazon, reviews can dramatically impact search rankings and conversions. Products with more reviews often outsell similar listings, which is why some brands try to boost review volume quickly by offering incentives. More reviews mean more visibility, and visibility often translates into sales.
Reviews influence buyer confidence and credibility, which is why a higher review count can make a product seem more trustworthy. Seeing a wide range of feedback—including both positive and negative—can increase a product’s credibility and make consumers feel more confident in their purchase decisions.
Not everything that glitters is gold, so here’s the catch: Using incentives can cross ethical and legal lines, especially if the review isn’t disclosed as incentivized. While incentivized reviews can provide a boost, they also raise serious questions about transparency and authenticity. Are they even allowed? Are brands risking their reputation—or worse, legal action—by trying to manipulate the system?
The short answer: not really—especially on major platforms. Most platforms have strict policies against undisclosed incentivized reviews, and violating them can lead to serious consequences like account suspension or review removal.
Amazon has a zero-tolerance stance on incentivized reviews unless they go through its official Vine program. Since 2016, the platform has removed thousands of listings and banned sellers who tried to get around the rules. Their policy is clear: “You may not provide compensation (including free or discounted products) for a review.”
Google doesn’t allow any kind of paid or incentivized reviews for businesses listed on Google Maps or in search. If detected, these reviews can be removed, and businesses may even face penalties in local rankings.
Platforms like Yelp and TripAdvisor use advanced systems to detect suspicious reviews. They often flag or remove reviews that appear to be influenced by compensation or free perks. In most cases, if you’re offering something in exchange for a review and not clearly disclosing it, you’re breaking the rules.
Let’s look at how these reviews typically show up in the real world:
A customer receives a free product—often through email outreach, social media, or third-party platforms—with the understanding that they’ll leave a review after trying it. While the brand may not explicitly require a positive review, there’s usually an unspoken expectation. If the reviewer doesn’t disclose that they received the product for free, it can be misleading to other buyers and violate platform rules.
This tactic involves asking customers to buy a product at full price and then promising a full refund once a review is posted. It creates the illusion of an unbiased, verified purchase when in reality, the review is still tied to compensation. Many sellers use this method to bypass platform filters—but it’s risky and often against terms of service.
Instead of offering a free product, some brands promise a gift card or cash payment in exchange for leaving a review. This form of compensation directly influences the content of the review, even if it's not stated outright. Platforms and the FTC consider this a form of deceptive marketing, especially when there’s no disclosure.
Brands may send free products to influencers with the hope of receiving positive content on social media or blogs. While gifting is common in influencer marketing, problems arise when the influencer doesn’t clearly state that the product was provided for free. This lack of transparency can mislead followers and violate advertising regulations, particularly FTC guidelines around sponsored content.
Incentivized reviews aren't unethical or misleading per se; it depends on the approach the brand chooses. If you take an ethical stance, allowing the influencer to give their honest opinion and clarifying that it's a collaboration, then there's no misleading.
Disloyalty plays a key role here, as it informs from the outset that it's a collaboration, and the audience knows the influencer was compensated for their review.
In these cases, if the content creator gives an honest opinion and mentions both the positive and negative aspects of the product, the potential customer will value it more than if it's all rosy.
There are a few regulatory guidelines, that along with the content usage rights are key to nail an incentivized reviews campaign without receiving penalties.
In the United States, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) requires that any material connection between a reviewer and a brand—such as receiving a free product, payment, or other incentive—must be clearly disclosed. The disclosure should be easy to understand, prominently placed, and not hidden in fine print or buried in a long list of hashtags.
For example, phrases like “I received this product for free in exchange for my honest review” or using #Ad or #Sponsored at the beginning of a post are considered acceptable. These rules apply not just to influencers, but also to brands and platforms that host or solicit reviews.
In the United Kingdom, the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) requires businesses to make it clear when a review has been incentivized and to ensure that the content is genuine and not misleading.
Similarly, in the European Union, the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive prohibits misleading commercial practices, which includes posting or promoting fake or undisclosed incentivized reviews. While the specifics may vary by region, the global trend is clear: full disclosure and authenticity are mandatory.
Failing to comply with disclosure rules can lead to serious penalties, including hefty fines and reputational damage. Major social media platforms like Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube have their own policies in place requiring influencers to label sponsored content.
For instance, Instagram has a “Paid Partnership” label that must be used, and failure to do so can result in removal of content, account suspension, or even bans in repeated cases. YouTube’s policies also require creators to check the “contains paid promotion” box when uploading sponsored videos.
Incentivized reviews aren’t just about handing out free products—it’s a structured process that brands use carefully to generate genuine, compliant feedback. Here’s a breakdown of how it typically works:
The first step for brands is to identify customers, influencers, or reviewers who align with their target audience. This might be done through email campaigns, loyalty programs, social media outreach, or influencer marketing platforms.
The key is to choose people who are genuinely interested in the product and whose opinions will resonate with potential buyers. You can find them among your clients, or use a free influencer finder tool if you plan to partner with influencers.
Once the right participants are selected, brands send the product or offer the reward. It's important at this stage to set expectations clearly: the goal is an honest review, not just a positive one.
Brands usually explain that transparency and truthful feedback are crucial to the collaboration.
After sending the product or reward, brands typically follow up with clear instructions about how and where to post the review—whether it’s on Amazon, Google, Yelp, social media, or the brand’s own website.
Many also include reminders or even sample phrases to ensure proper disclosure, helping reviewers stay compliant with FTC or international regulations.
To streamline the process, many brands rely on specialized tools and platforms. For product sampling and customer reviews, services like Bazaarvoice, Influenster, PowerReviews, and Trustpilot are commonly used.
When working with influencers, brands often turn to platforms like Influencer Hero, which help with vetting, contracting, and tracking campaign performance.
When managed carefully, incentivized reviews can become a powerful part of a brand’s customer engagement strategy.
Transparency, authenticity, and a clear structure help ensure that reviews build trust rather than damage it—making the effort worthwhile for both brands and their audiences.
They can only be done through Amazon’s Vine Program, where Amazon itself invites trusted reviewers to receive free products in exchange for honest feedback. Any attempts by sellers to offer incentives—like discounts, freebies, or payment—for reviews outside of Vine violate Amazon’s guidelines and can result in account suspension or removal.
No, Google’s policies clearly state that businesses are not allowed to offer incentives—monetary or otherwise—in exchange for reviews. This includes discounts, free items, or special offers. Incentivizing reviews can lead to penalties such as the removal of reviews, a drop in local ranking, or even a suspension of your Google Business Profile.
Before you jump on the incentivized review bandwagon, there are a number of best practices you should keep in mind to ensure it's a successful method and doesn't damage your customers' trust in your brand. Here's a quick overview:
For an incentivized review to be effective, your audience needs to know it's a paid collaboration. This is a way to maintain followers' trust, as the influencer isn't hiding the profit behind their review.
The best way to effectively advertise an incentivized review is to include the hashtag or the word "Ad" in the post. It doesn't matter if the content creator gives a less-than-positive review (3 stars or lower), as there's still a collaboration behind it, which is enough to announce the presence of an ad.
Other words could be "collab," or more explicitly, "paid test." This way, the influencer makes it clear that they received payment for the review, but this will not influence their opinion of the product or service.
Disclosure statements must be visible, as the idea is not to mislead the audience, but rather to make them aware that the influencer received payment for their review. It's best to include them in the post's copy, either at the beginning or at the end in hashtag format (for example, #ad #paid test #collab among others).
If a product or service is good enough to be marketed, then there's nothing to fear from an influencer's honest review. Pretend they're just another customer; they just have the ability to expose your product to a larger audience. Allow them to set their own tone and express themselves freely.
Just because an influencer is neutral doesn't mean they can't give your product a good rating. Rather, it reflects the honesty with which they review it, and how their personal opinions can be featured in the review.
Followers are familiar with the influencer's tone; they regularly watch their videos or content in general. So, if anything sounds off-topic, it will set off alarm bells and lower the credibility of the collaboration.
Incentivized reviews aren't an everyday marketing strategy, so they must be planned and executed accordingly.
If your brand or business is launching a new product, incentivized reviews are one of the best influencer marketing campaigns you can run because you're showcasing what's new, along with real opinions from content creators.
A good idea is to do this before the product is released, so you start generating buzz and create a desire among potential customers to purchase it. You can combine it with giveaways so that a lucky member of the influencer's audience also tries it, multiplying the campaign's effectiveness.
As we said, incentivized reviews should be distributed not only over time but also across influencer accounts. At this point, less is more, and it's advisable to partner with a small number of influencers, whose followings aren't exactly the same (otherwise they'll feel bombarded by the ad) but can still be from the same niche.
We recommend establishing a posting schedule and ensuring that different content creators post their posts with space between them, so they have greater authenticity and don't clash with each other.
When incentivizing reviews, it’s critical to encourage honesty rather than aiming for perfect scores. Authentic feedback—whether positive or slightly critical—helps build long-term trust with your audience.
If a customer leaves a negative review, don't delete it. Instead, respond professionally, offer support, and show your willingness to improve. This approach showcases your brand’s authenticity and commitment to customer satisfaction.
%20(1).png)
Displaying a trust badge on your site or product page signals to potential customers that your brand values transparency and honest feedback.
Some popular badges include "Verified Reviews," "Independent Feedback," or certifications from third-party review platforms. These badges can enhance credibility and reassure customers that your reviews—whether incentivized or organic—are genuine.
Another important consideration: monetary payments for reviews are prohibited on almost all major review platforms (such as Amazon, Google, Yelp, and TripAdvisor) and are more likely to lead to biased or dishonest feedback.
Instead of paying for reviews, offer non-monetary incentives that still add value for the reviewer without compromising authenticity. Some great alternatives include:
By using non-monetary incentives, you align better with platform guidelines, maintain the trust of your audience, and create more genuine brand advocates.
There are some risks if incentivized reviews are not carried out carefully. They are easy to avoid, especially if you are aware of them, so we will share them with you here.
Not all platforms are fans of incentivized reviews, and many have specific penalties when they perceive them.
Marketplaces like Amazon prohibit, for example, asking a regular customer to leave a positive review if they liked the product. So, if they notice that you are increasing the number of positive reviews with spammy content (similar text, inauthentic reviews, etc.), they may temporarily ban your seller account.
The best way to conduct incentivized reviews through Amazon is with the help of Amazon’s Influencer Marketing Platform, where you can pair with content creators and they will share and publish reviews about your products.
The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has made it clear that failing to disclose incentivized reviews is a violation of consumer protection laws. Brands or influencers who post or host undisclosed incentivized reviews can face serious legal consequences, including hefty fines.
In recent years, the FTC has issued warning letters and taken enforcement action against companies that misled consumers by masking paid endorsements as genuine opinions.
Penalties can reach tens of thousands of dollars per violation, and repeat offenses can lead to lawsuits or long-term damage to a company's credibility. Staying compliant with FTC guidelines isn't just best practice—it's a legal necessity.
Building a positive reputation is complex, as we know that ultimately, brands and companies need sales to survive. However, if an incentivized review campaign is carried out without following the guidelines mentioned in the best practices section, or if this method is used excessively, it could damage your brand's reputation.
If potential customers perceive that there was manipulation to get the influencer's review to be positive, then they will respond negatively to the collaboration. They don't need to criticize it in the comments on the post; they simply won't buy your product.
That's why it's crucial to ensure the authenticity of the collaboration and give the influencer freedom. Honesty goes a long way, and customers prefer to hear the true pros and cons of a product before making a decision, rather than hearing everything is positive and then finding a product that doesn't meet their expectations.
Once potential customers perceive that the brand regularly relies on incentivized reviews to promote its products, they will stop believing in the brand and the true added value of the products they sell.
For example, Sephora users noticed that a large number of the reviews on their own website were incentivized reviews. Some of the red flags were reviews that had the same copy but were posted through different accounts. They also noted that the reviews were "brief and generic," which doesn't match the opinions of people who actually used the product and had opinions about it.
This damages the credibility of a globally recognized brand like Sephora, so you should definitely take these red flags into account and ensure your incentivized reviews don't fall under them.
If you’re a brand or seller, here’s how you can collect authentic, policy-compliant reviews:
Sending a polite follow-up email after a purchase is a great way to ask for reviews without pressuring your customers. By simply asking for feedback, you give customers the opportunity to share their experience in a genuine and voluntary way.
Instead of offering incentives for reviews, try offering loyalty points or discounts on future purchases. This way, you can encourage engagement and repeat business without crossing ethical lines.
Platforms like Trustpilot or Judge.me offer tools that help you collect reviews while staying compliant with policies and guidelines. These platforms ensure that reviews are genuine and transparent, which can build long-term trust with your customers.
Great customer service can go a long way in inspiring organic, unsolicited reviews. When customers are satisfied with their experience, they are more likely to share their thoughts without needing an incentive.
Bonus Tip: If you’re offering free samples, make sure you require clear disclosure from the reviewer. This ensures transparency and keeps you in line with platform policies.
Buyers should stay vigilant. Here’s how you can identify suspicious reviews:
If a review is filled with generic praise but lacks real, detailed insight into how the product works or feels, it could be incentivized. Authentic reviews usually include specifics that show the reviewer actually used the product.
Identical or near-identical reviews across different products or sellers are a major red flag. It often suggests bulk reviewing in exchange for rewards or incentives.
A sudden influx of positive reviews immediately after launch can indicate a brand has pushed for incentivized feedback to gain early traction.
On platforms like Amazon, genuine reviews are typically marked with a “Verified Purchase” badge. If many reviews lack this badge, especially early on, it’s worth questioning their legitimacy.
Influencers and bloggers are required to disclose when they’ve received compensation or free products. If that disclosure is missing, the review may not be trustworthy—or even compliant with FTC guidelines.
ProTip: Look for balanced reviews that mention both pros and cons. Too many glowing, one-sided reviews could be a sign that something’s off.
Now that you know the best practices for successful incentivized reviews, and what you should avoid, we can explore some of the most successful incentivized reviews campaigns.
Coca-Cola was introducing the new version of its "Coca-Cola Zero" line in Eastern European countries, but it wasn't the sales success they had hoped for. Therefore, they partnered with influencers in the region to try this new version of Coca-Cola and post reviews on their social media, primarily Instagram and TikTok.
The influencers who collaborated with Coca-Cola gave their honest answers, and did so organically, showing this product as part of their daily routine. While this seemed spontaneous, they clarified in the post that it was a partnership with Coca-Cola, and the soft drink brand also shared this content on its social media. This transparency contributed to the brand's credibility and led to a boost in Coca-Cola Zero sales in the country.
Putnam Books, a renowned book publisher, wanted to promote the release of a new book. To achieve this, they partnered with NetGalley, a platform that provides free books to booktokers, bloggers, and others who share this type of content. The influencer receives the book for free and, in return, publishes their review of it on social media or a blog.
The collaboration with Putnam Books was based on authenticity: the influencers gave their real and honest opinions about the book, highlighting its highs and lows. These weren't generic reviews, but rather in-depth discussions about what they thought about the book (without giving away spoilers). This gave potential customers a sneak peek into the content and enticed them to read more. Furthermore, by being influencers in the book niche, Putnam Books ensured that their followers would be interested in buying books, being their exact target audience.
LEGO renewed its partnership with Disney by creating the "Brick Headz" line featuring the company's characters, but sales were slow to pick up. To boost the trend, they teamed up with influencers from the board game and art niches, as well as Disney vloggers. They received LEGOs to build the characters for free in exchange for providing honest reviews and sharing it to their audience.
LEGO and Disney are a match made in heaven, but this incentivized review campaign helped them reach a larger audience, who asked for instructions on how to buy the products in the comments on the posts. The product is good and reasonably priced, so even when the reviews weren't 100% positive—for example, there were differences from the original character's design—this didn't negatively impact sales.
Incentivized reviews, when executed ethically and transparently, can be a powerful marketing tool. They help build credibility, generate buzz, and provide valuable feedback—especially during product launches. But it’s crucial to follow legal guidelines, disclose all incentives clearly, and allow reviewers to express genuine opinions.
By putting authenticity first and avoiding overuse, brands can strike the right balance between promotion and trust. Done right, incentivized reviews won’t just drive sales—they’ll build lasting customer relationships grounded in transparency and honesty.
Not necessarily. While many platforms permit incentivized content, they require clear disclosures. Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube all have their own branded content policies. For example, YouTube requires creators to mark videos as containing paid promotion, and Instagram has a “Paid Partnership” tag. Always check the latest platform guidelines before launching a campaign.
Absolutely. In fact, incentivized reviews can be a smart growth tactic for small brands trying to gain social proof quickly. Partnering with micro-influencers in niche markets often provides higher engagement and better ROI than celebrity endorsements. Just make sure all incentives and disclosures comply with local regulations.
A paid endorsement is typically more promotional and brand-controlled, often requiring specific messaging or content. An incentivized review, while compensated, is supposed to be honest, unscripted feedback based on actual product use. The key difference lies in creative control—reviewers maintain more freedom.
It depends on the product type. For physical products, wait until the reviewer has had enough time to use it—this could range from a few days (like for beauty products) to a few weeks (like tech or fitness gear). Rushing the process may result in shallow or unhelpful feedback, which undermines the campaign.
Yes—especially for written reviews on blogs or eCommerce platforms. When incentivized reviews contain genuine, keyword-rich feedback, they can improve your product's visibility on search engines. However, avoid spammy or duplicate content, as this can hurt rankings. Google also expects sponsored content to include proper disclosure and rel="sponsored" tags for links.
Schedule a Demo with one of our media experts below.
