How to Spot Fake Instagram Accounts - 5 Ways to Identify

May 24, 2024
11 Min
Peter Nettesheim
| Author
See Which Influencers Follow Your Instagram
They are 8X more likely to work with you

How to Spot Fake Instagram Accounts - 5 Ways to Identify

Instagram, with over a billion users, is a prime platform for social media marketing and personal branding. However, the rise of fake Instagram accounts poses a significant challenge. These accounts can distort engagement metrics, mislead users, and harm brand credibility. 

For businesses, especially those involved in influencer marketing, the presence of fake accounts can drastically undermine campaign effectiveness. Influencer marketing campaigns rely heavily on genuine engagement and reach. Collaborating with influencers who have a high number of fake followers can result in wasted marketing budgets and poor campaign performance. Identifying and avoiding fake accounts is crucial to ensure that marketing efforts yield the desired results.

What are Fake Instagram Accounts?

Fake Instagram accounts differ from genuine accounts in that they do not represent real users who are genuinely interested in the content or products being shared. Instead, they serve to artificially boost metrics such as follower count, likes, and comments, creating the illusion of popularity and influence.

They are usually created to do mass-following, share spam business proposals or maybe even to communicate shady information in general. 

The Negative Impact of Fake Instagram Accounts

Distorted Engagement Metrics

Fake accounts often result in inflated follower counts but low engagement rates. This discrepancy can make it difficult to gauge the true reach and effectiveness of your content and of your influencer campaign. When your engagement metrics are skewed, it becomes challenging to make informed decisions about your social media strategy. 

Brands might mistakenly believe they have a broad audience when, in reality, they are reaching far fewer genuine users.

For influencer marketing campaigns, this distortion can lead to ineffective targeting and poor ROI, as campaigns may be directed at non-existent or uninterested audiences.

Eroded Trust and Credibility

Trust is crucial in any business relationship. If your audience or potential collaborators discover that a significant portion of your followers are fake, it can severely damage your credibility. This erosion of trust can lead to reduced customer loyalty and difficulty in forming new partnerships. Authenticity is key on social media, and fake followers can undermine the perceived authenticity of your brand.

Furthermore, influencers who have a predominant fake following will not provide real results, as the credibility score will be very low.

Wasted Marketing Resources

Investing time and money in growing your Instagram presence only to have it diluted by fake accounts is a waste of resources. Marketing campaigns that rely on inaccurate engagement data can be less effective, leading to poor ROI. Brands might also spend money on influencers with fake followers, believing they are reaching a larger audience than they actually are. This misallocation of resources can significantly affect the overall success of your marketing strategies.

Poor Targeting and Conversion Rates

Fake accounts do not engage with your content, make purchases, or spread the word about your brand. They skew your analytics, making it harder to understand your real audience. As a result, your marketing campaigns may fail to target the right demographics, leading to poor conversion rates and ineffective marketing strategies.

5 Signs of Fake Instagram Accounts

1. Unusual Follower-to-Engagement Ratio

One of the most telling signs of a fake account is an unusual follower-to-engagement ratio. Accounts with a large number of followers but minimal likes or comments on their posts are often fake. Genuine engagement is usually consistent with follower count.

2. Generic or Stolen Content

Fake accounts frequently post generic, low-quality, or stolen content. They may also repost images without proper attribution. These accounts lack the unique and personal touch that genuine users add to their posts. Authentic accounts typically share original content and personal stories that resonate with their audience.

3. Incomplete Profiles

A real Instagram account typically includes a complete profile with a bio, profile picture, and a reasonable number of posts. Fake accounts, on the other hand, often have incomplete profiles. They may lack a profile picture, have a vague bio, or feature a disproportionate number of posts given their follower count.

4. Irrelevant Comments

Another indicator is the presence of irrelevant or generic comments on posts. Comments like "Nice pic!" or emojis alone are common tactics used by fake accounts to appear active. Genuine interactions are more meaningful and relevant to the content.

5. Sudden Spike in Followers

A sudden, unexplained increase in followers is a potential sign of a fake account. Authentic growth is usually gradual and steady. Fake accounts often experience sudden spikes as a result of purchasing followers.

How Influencer Hero's Instagram Follower Analytics Can Help

Detecting fake accounts manually can be time-consuming and challenging. Influencer Hero offers a powerful Instagram follower analytics tool designed to help users identify fake accounts effortlessly. 

This tool analyzes follower quality, engagement rates, and growth patterns, providing detailed insights that highlight suspicious activity. By leveraging Influencer Hero, businesses and individuals can ensure their Instagram engagement is genuine and trustworthy, as well as enhance the effectiveness of influencer marketing campaigns.

The tool is also available as a Chrome extension to quickly run a fact-check while visiting an influencer’s profile. You can download the Instagram follower analytics extension here.

How to Identify True Influencers for Your Brand

As we have learnt throughout this article, securing authentic Instagram influencers for your brand campaign is vital for achieving a successful marketing strategy.

Find influencers - the old fashion way:

Using Instagram’s search functionality to find posts, accounts, and hashtags that lead you to influencers already discussing topics that matter to your brand. To get here, start by clearly identifying your target audience. Understanding their demographics and interests will help you pinpoint influencers whose follower base aligns with your brand. Perform in-depth research on hashtags relevant to your industry, and don’t forget extra analytics tools for enhanced research, like Influencer Hero’s Instagram follower analytics tool and Instagram engagement rate checker tool.

To ensure the accounts you find appealing aren’t fake, investigate the influencer’s comment sections to gauge real engagement. Look for substantial interactions, meaningful conversations, and positive responses. These indicators reveal a genuine connection with their audience. Once you’ve found influencers who fit your brand, initiate contact with a personalized message. Outline your campaign details, set expectations, and discuss terms for collaboration.

Find influencers - the quick and easy way:

Finding the right influencers can be challenging and time-consuming. Luckily, there are platforms that make the process easier like Influencer Hero, which is a leading influencer marketing platform that helps brands connect with genuine influencers. 

Our comprehensive search tools allow you to filter influencers by interests, engagement rates, and follower demographics. With our platform, you can ensure that the influencers you collaborate with have authentic followings and meaningful engagement. This not only enhances the effectiveness of your marketing campaigns but also maximizes your ROI. 


Fake Instagram accounts undermine the integrity of social media engagement and can mislead users, erode trust, waste marketing resources, and lead to poor targeting and conversion rates. By being vigilant and using tools that aid your research, you can effectively spot and mitigate the impact of these accounts. 

Ensuring the authenticity of your Instagram interactions not only protects your brand but also enhances the quality of your social media presence, particularly in influencer marketing campaigns. Identifying and avoiding fake accounts is crucial to maximizing the effectiveness of your marketing efforts and ensuring that your campaigns reach genuine, engaged audiences.

What are fake Instagram accounts and why are they created?
What should I look for in an account's profile to determine if it is fake?
How can fake Instagram accounts impact my business's social media strategy?
What are the risks of investing in influencers with fake followers?
What steps can brands take to ensure they are collaborating with genuine influencers?

Most Popular Blogs

Ready to achieve 10X+ ROI?

Schedule a Demo with one of our media experts below.